Filtering Working Papers

05-13

Doron Avramov, Russ Wermers

Investing in Mutual Funds when Returns are Predictable

published in: Journal of Financial Economics, Vol. 81, 2006, 339-377.
DOI: 10.1111/j.1540-6261.2006.01015.x

This paper analyzes the performance of portfolio strategies that invest in no-load, open-end U.S. domestic equity mutual funds, incorporating predictability in (i) manager skills, (ii) fund risk-loadings, and (iii) benchmark returns. Predictability in manager skills is found to be the dominant source of investment profitability – long-only strategies that incorporate such predictability considerably outperform prior-documented “hot-hands” and “smart-money” strategies, and generate positive and significant performance with respect to the Fama-French and momentum benchmarks. Specifically, these strategies outperform their benchmarks by 2-4% per year through their ability to time industries over the business cycle. Moreover, they choose individual funds that outperform their industry benchmarks to achieve an additional 3-6% per year. Overall, our findings indicate that industries are important in locating outperforming mutual funds, and that active management adds much more value than documented by prior studies.
05-12

Knut Griese

Liquiditätsdynamik am deutschen Aktienmarkt

published in: DBW - Die Betriebswirtschaft, Vol. 66, 2006, 402-418.

This paper examines liquidity in the German stock market, focusing on the price impact of trades. We first use a simple dynamic optimisation model to show how an investor’s optimal trading strategy depends on the functional form of the price impact function. We then estimate this function using order book data from XETRA. We find that the assumption of price impact being linear in order size, which is commonly used in the literature, is not supported by the data. The price impact function is convex in approximately half of the cases and concave in the other half. Changes in its shape are not purely random and can be forecast well using a VAR(1) model. A linear model delivers substantially lower forecast accuracy. Our findings imply that investors in the German stock market can save a substantial proportion of liquidity-related transaction costs by adapting their trading strategies to liquidity dynamics.
05-11

Silke Ber, Alexander Kempf, Stefan Ruenzi

Determinanten der Mittelzuflüsse bei deutschen Aktienfonds

published in: zfbf - Schmalenbachs Zeitschrift für betriebswirtschaftliche Forschung, Vol. 59, 2007, 35-60.

This paper provides the first empirical analysis of the determinants of flows into German equity funds. For the period from 1991 to 2003, we find several interesting differences from the US market. First, we confirm the positive convex relationship between a fund’s past performance and its net flows documented in the literature, although this relationship is less pronounced in Germany than in the United States. We also show that the characteristics of the fund management company to which a fund belongs have a substantial influence on its flows. In particular, we provide the first evidence of a cannibalisation effect within fund families, especially among funds offered in the same market segment. Our findings have important implications for fund managers’ risk-taking and the product policies of fund management companies.
05-10

Michaela Bär, Alexander Kempf, Stefan Ruenzi

Is a Team Different From the Sum of Its Parts? Evidence from Mutual Fund Managers

published in: Review of Finance, Vol. 15, 2011, 359-396.
DOI: 10.1093/rof/rfq014

This paper provides the first empirical test of the diversification of opinions theory and the group shift theory using real business data. Our data set covers management teams and single managers of US equity mutual funds. Our results reject the group shift theory and support the diversification of opinions theory: extreme opinions of single team managers average out and, consequently, teams make less extreme decisions than individuals do. We find that teams follow less extreme investment styles and their portfolios are less industry concentrated than those of single managers and that teams are eventually less likely to achieve extreme performance outcomes. These results hold after taking into account the impact of fund and family characteristics as well as manager characteristics. Additionally, teams exhibit a lower active share and lower risk levels, driven by a lower level of idiosyncratic risk, as compared to singlemanaged funds.
05-09

Mathias Hoffmann

Saving, Investment and the Net Foreign Asset Position

Over the last two decades, countries have exhibited net foreign assets and liabilities. This paper develops an empirical model to examine the causes for the stock of the net foreign asset positions in 51 developing and industrialised countries. The reasons for significantly high or low net foreign asset positions can be derived from long-run trend differences in saving and investment. Using cointegration techniques, it is shown that GDP per capita, public debt and demographic factors influence long-run saving and investment and, hence, net external wealth of developing and industrialised countries.
05-08

Stefan Ruenzi

Mutual Fund Growth in Standard an Specialist Market Segments

published in: Financial Markets and Portfolio Management, Vol. 19, 2005, 153-167.
DOI: 10.1007/s11408-005-3383-3

This paper is concerned with differences in the performance-flow relationship (PFR) between standard and specialist market segments of the mutual fund industry. We expect differences in this relationship because investor characteristics might vary across different segments. Our results show that the PFR is more convex in standard segments as compared to specialist segments. Furthermore, investors in standard segments are less risk-averse and invest more in high-load funds than investors in specialist segments. Our findings are consistent with investors in standard segments being less sophisticated than investors in specialist segments and to rely more heavily on the advice of financial brokers, which is compensated for by load fees.
05-07

Alexander Kempf, Stefan Ruenzi

Status Quo Bias and the Number of Alternatives – An Empirical Illustration from the Mutual Fund Industry

published in: Journal of Behavioral Finance, Vol. 7, 2006, 204-213.
DOI: 10.1207/s15427579jpfm0704_3

We examine the extent of the Status Quo Bias (SQB) in a real-world repeated decision situation. Individuals who are subject to a SQB tend to choose an alternative that was chosen previously (i.e. their status quo), even if it is not the optimal choice any more. We examine the US equity mutual fund market and find strong evidence for the existence of a SQB in this market. Furthermore, the SQB is more severe in segments where there are more funds to choose from. Thereby, we deliver the first empirical confirmation of the experimental result of Samuelson and Zeckhauser (1988), that the SQB positively depends on the number of alternatives.
05-06

Joachim Grammig, Erik Theissen

Is BEST Really Better? Internalization of Orders in an Open Limit Order Book

published in: Schmalenbach Business Review, Vol. 64, 2012, 82-100.
DOI: 10.1007/BF03396891

This paper studies the market quality of an internalization system which is designed as part of an open limit order book (the Xetra system operated by Deutsche Börse AG). The internalization system (Xetra BEST) guarantees a price improvement over the inside spread in the Xetra order book. We develop a structural model of this unique dual market environment and show that, while adverse selection costs of internalized trades are significantly lower than those of regular order book trades, the realized spreads (the revenue earned by the suppliers of liquidity) is significantly larger. The cost savings of the internalizer are larger than the mandatory price improvement. This suggests that internalization can be profitable both for the customer and the internalizer.
05-05

Héléna Beltran-Lopez, Joachim Grammig, Albert J. Menkveld

Limit order books and trade informativeness

published in: European Journal of Finance, Vol. 18, 2012, 737-759.
DOI: 10.1080/1351847X.2011.601651

Electronic limit order books are ubiquitous in markets today. However, theoretical models for limit order markets fail to explain the real world data well. Sandas (2001) tests the classic Glosten (1994) model for order book equilibrium and rejects it. We reconfirm this result for one of the largest European stock markets. We then relax one of the model’s assumptions and allow the informational content of trades to change over time. Adapting Hasbrouck’s (1991a,b) methodology to estimate time varying trade informativeness we find that it is a slowly mean reverting process. By conditioning on trade informativeness, we find support for the Glosten model’s implication that books are more shallow during times of informative market orders. However, a high level of liquidity supply is committed up to an economically significant trade size volume, even when trade informativeness is high. This can be seen as a vindication of the open order book design which dispenses with dedicated market makers. We also find evidence for a market order trader population which is quite heterogenous with respect to price sensitivity.
05-04

Mathias Hoffmann

Compensating Wages under Different Exchange Rate Regimes

This paper analyses the interconnectedness between developing countries’ domestic wage levels and their exchange rate choices. The theoretical model illustrates that differences in domestic wage levels are related to countries’ exchange rate regimes. In particular, the level of domestic wages increases with the rigidity of the exchange rate regime. The empirical model explores the determinants of the domestic wage level in a cross-section of 38 developing countries. In line with the theoretical model, the economies under review experience a rise in the domestic wage level with an increase in the rigidity of their exchange rate regime.