Filtering Working Papers

15-14

Markus Doumet, Peter Limbach, Erik Theissen

Ich bin dann mal weg: Werteffekte von Delistings deutscher Aktiengesellschaften nach dem Frosta-Urteil

published in: zfbf - Schmalenbach's Journal of Business Research, Vol. 68, 2016, 253-277.
DOI: 10.1007/s41471-016-0016-7

With the controversial decision in the “Frosta” case, Germany’s Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof) has made significant changes to the rules that apply to corporate delistings from German stock exchanges. The mandatory approval of the delisting by shareholders and the minority shareholders’ claim for indemnity have been abolished. This study examines the consequences of the new ruling for shareholders for the period from the court decision in October 2013 to May 2015. The cumulative abnormal stock return in the three days around the announcement of a delisting amounts to -6%. For the vast majority of all delisting announcements, the stock price reaction is found to be negative. We do not observe significant price declines after downlistings. We do observe, however, a deterioration of liquidity in these cases. The results call upon the legislator to take action in order to protect minority shareholders, at least in the case of complete delistings.
15-15

Stephan Jank, Esad Smajbegovic

Dissecting Short-Sale Performance: Evidence from Large Position Disclosures

Short sellers are perceived as informed, sophisticated investors. Yet little is known about their actual performance and trading strategies. Using a novel, hand-collected data set of daily position disclosures in Europe, we identify the entry, change, and exit dates of large short-sale positions for a wide cross section of stocks and investors. We find that hedge funds, the predominant investor group, generate an annualized Fama and French (1993) risk-adjusted return of about 5.5%, outperforming other investors. Evidence indicates that hedge funds act as arbitrageurs, generating their returns by trading on the mispricing-related factors, e.g. momentum, betting-against-beta, and quality-minus-junk. In the cross section of hedge funds, local, diversified, and active funds outperform their counterparts. On the position level, we document a first-mover advantage. The profitability of short sales also varies significantly with investors’ holding period, location, and industry experience.
15-16

David Blake, Alberto G. Rossi, Allan Timmermann, Ian Tonks, Russ Wermers

Network Centrality and Pension Fund Performance

published in: Journal of Financial Economics, Vol. 128, 2018, 183-206.
DOI: 10.1016/j.jfineco.2018.02.003

We analyze the relation between the location of a pension fund in its network and the investment performance, risk taking, and flows of the fund. Our approach analyzes the centrality of the fund’s management company by examining the number of connections it has with other management companies through their commonality in managing for the same fund sponsors or through the same fund consultants. Network centrality is found to be positively associated with risk-adjusted return performance and growth in assets under management, after controlling for size and past performance, for domestic asset classes; however, we do not find this relation for foreign equity holdings. These findings indicate that local information advantages, which are much stronger among managers holding locally based stocks, exhibit positive externalities among connected managers. Of particular note is that we do not find that the centrality of a manager within one asset class (e.g., domestic bonds) helps the performance of the manager in another asset class (e.g., domestic equity), further indicating that our network analysis uncovers information di↵usion e↵ects. Network connections established through consultants are found to be particularly significant in explaining performance and fund flows, consistent with consultants acting as an important information conduit through which managers learn about each other’s actions. Moreover, the importance of network centrality is strongest for larger funds, controlling for any economic scale e↵ects. Better connected funds are also better able to attract higher net inflows for a given level of past return performance. Finally, more centrally placed fund managers are less likely to be fired after spells of low performance. Our results indicate that networks in asset management are one key source of the dissemination of private information about security values.
15-17

Olaf Korn, Laura-Chloé Kuntz

Low-beta Strategies

This paper analyzes trading strategies designed to exploit the low-beta anomaly. Although the notion of buying low-beta stocks and selling high-beta stocks is natural, a choice is necessary with respect to the relative weighting of high-beta stocks and low-beta stocks in the portfolio. Our empirical results for US stocks show that this choice is very important for the risk-return characteristics of the resulting portfolios and their sensitivities to common risk factors. The weighting of stocks within the low-beta and high-beta portfolios and the chosen investment universe are essential design elements of low-beta strategies too. If smaller firms are excluded, risk-adjusted returns of low-beta strategies can even become insignificant.
16-01

Gjergji Cici, Scott Gibson, Claire Rosenfeld

Cross-Company Effects of Common Ownership: Dealings Between Borrowers and Lenders With a Common Blockholder

We study the effects of common ownership on syndicated loan market interactions. We find that borrowers and lenders that are commonly held by an institutional blockholder tended to do more business together going forward than those that are not commonly held. We hypothesize that the increased likelihood of striking a deal derives from conversations between borrowers and blockholders about financing plans, which in turn increases borrowers’ familiarity and perhaps opinion of commonly owned lenders. Consistent with this view, we find that the increase in dealings occurred only when the blockholder followed an active rather than a passive investment strategy.
16-02

Antonio Gargano, Alberto G. Rossi, Russ Wermers

The Freedom of Information Act and the Race Towards Information Acquisition

published in: Review of Financial Studies, Vol. 30, 2017, 2179-2228.
DOI: 10.1093/rfs/hhw035

We document a little-known source of information exploited by sophisticated institutional investors: the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), a law that allows for the disclosure of previously unreleased information by the U.S. Government. Through FOIA requests, we identify several sophisticated institutional investors, chiefly hedge funds, that request information from the FDA. We explore the type of information commonly requested by funds and the types of firms that are targets of FDA-FOIA requests, and we show that FOIA requests allow these investors to generate abnormal returns. Thus, we illustrate a detailed mechanism through which costly information becomes incorporated into market prices.
16-03

Thorsten Martin, Florian Sonnenburg

Managerial Ownership Changes and Mutual Fund Performance

We study the dynamics of fund manager ownership for a sample of U.S. equity mutual funds from 2005 to 2011. We find that ownership changes positively predict changes in future risk-adjusted fund performance. A one-standarddeviation increase in ownership predicts a 1.6 percent increase in alpha in the following year. Fund managers who are required to increase their ownership by fund family policy show the strongest increase in alpha. They do so by increasing their trading activity in line with the view that higher ownership aligns interests of managers with those of shareholders and induces higher effort.
16-04

Peter Gomber, Satchit Sagade, Erik Theissen, Moritz Christian Weber, Christian Westheide

Spoilt for Choice: Determinants of Market Shares in Fragmented Equity Markets

published in: Journal of Financial Markets, Vol. 64, 2023, article 100816.
DOI: 10.1016/j.finmar.2023.100816

The equity trading landscape all over the world has changed dramatically in recent years. We have witnessed the advent of new trading venues and significant changes in the market shares of existing ones. We use an extensive panel dataset from the European equity markets to analyze the market shares of five categories of lit and dark trading mechanisms. Market design features, such as minimum tick size, immediacy and anonymity; market conditions, such as liquidity and volatility; and the informational environment have distinct implications for order routing decisions and trading venues’ resulting market shares. Furthermore, these implications differ distinctly for small and large trades, probably because traders jointly optimize their trade size and venue choice. Our results both confirm and go beyond current theoretical predictions on trading in fragmented markets.
16-05

Erik Theissen, Christian Westheide

Call of Duty: Designated Market Maker Participation in Call Auctions

published in: Journal of Financial Markets, Vol. 49, 2020, article 100530.
DOI: 10.1016/j.finmar.2019.100530

Many equity markets combine continuous trading and call auctions. Oftentimes designated market makers (DMMs) supply additional liquidity. Whereas prior research has focused on their role in continuous trading, we provide a detailed analysis of their activity in call auctions. Using data from Germany’s Xetra system, we find that DMMs are most active when they can provide the greatest benefits to the market, i.e., in relatively illiquid stocks and at times of elevated volatility. They stabilize prices and trade profitably.
16-06

Olaf Korn, Marc Oliver Rieger

Hedging with Regret

published in: Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance, Vol. 22, 2019, 192-205.
DOI: 10.1016/j.jbef.2019.03.002

This paper investigates corporate hedging under regret aversion. Regret-averse firms try to avoid deviations of their hedging policy from the ex post best policy, an intuitive consideration if one has to justify one’s decisions afterward. The study presents a model of a firm that faces uncertain prices and seeks to hedge both profit risk and regret risk with derivatives. It characterizes optimal hedge positions and shows that regret aversion leads to stronger incentives to hedge downside price risk than standard expected utility theory. In the profit region of the price distribution, however, regret aversion reduces the hedging of price risk to avoid large regret in the case of increasing prices. The results show that regret aversion has a strong effect on the choice of the hedging instrument and provides a preference-based explanation for the use of options in corporate risk management.