Filtering Working Papers

21-05

Gjergji Cici, Alex Zhang

On the Valuation Skills of Corporate Bond Mutual Funds

published in: Review of Finance, Vol. 28, 2024, 2017-2049.
DOI: 10.1093/rof/rfae028

The corporate bond market is larger, more illiquid, and presumably less efficient than the equity market. These features provide numerous profit opportunities for corporate bond mutual funds that are unique to the corporate bond market. However, whether corporate bond mutual funds have the valuation skills needed to take advantage of these opportunities is unclear. We introduce a novel measure to assess the valuation skills of investment-grade corporate bond mutual funds, which we refer to as the valuation accuracy score (VAS). VAS recognizes funds holding more underpriced and less overpriced corporate bonds as ex-ante having better valuation skills. It predicts future fund performance, is stable over time, and is unrelated to other sources of skill. Investors chase the performance of higher-VAS funds more aggressively and exhibit a convex flow-performance relation among these funds.
21-06

Vikas Agarwal, Hadiye Aslan, Lixin Huang, Honglin Ren

Political Uncertainty and Household Stock Market Participation

published in: Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, Vol. 57, 2022, 2899-2928.
DOI: 10.1017/S0022109022000114

Using micro-level panel data and a difference-in-differences identification strategy, we study the effect of political uncertainty on household stock market participation. We find that households significantly reduce their participation and reallocate funds to safer assets during periods of increased political uncertainty. The decline in participation is related to households’ response to elevated asset risk and their incentive to hedge increased labor income risk. In situations where uncertainty remains high after elections, pre-election reduction in participation is only partially reversed, reflecting a prolonged distortion in household stock investments, which can have implications for households, firms, and the economy in general.
21-07

Fousseni Chabi-Yo, Markus Huggenberger, Florian Weigert

Multivariate Crash Risk

published in: Journal of Financial Economics, Vol. 145, 2022, 129-153.
DOI: 10.1016/j.jfineco.2021.07.016

This paper investigates whether multivariate crash risk (MCRASH), defined as exposure to extreme realizations of multiple systematic factors, is priced in the cross-section of expected stock returns. We derive an extended linear model with a positive premium for MCRASH and we empirically confirm that stocks with high MCRASH earn significantly higher future returns than stocks with low MCRASH. The premium is not explained by linear factor exposures, alternative downside risk measures or stock characteristics. Extending market-based definitions of crash risk to other well-established factors helps to determine the cross-section of expected stock returns without further expanding the factor zoo.
21-08

Turan G. Bali, Heiner Beckmeyer, Mathis Mörke, Florian Weigert

Option Return Predictability with Machine Learning and Big Data

published in: Review of Financial Studies, Vol. 36, 2023, 3548-3602.
DOI: 10.1093/rfs/hhad017

Drawing upon more than 12 million observations over the period from 1996 to 2020, we find that allowing for nonlinearities significantly increases the out-of-sample performance of option and stock characteristics in predicting future option returns. Besides statistical significance, the nonlinear machine learning models generate economically sizeable profits in the long-short portfolios of equity options even after accounting for transaction costs. Although option-based characteristics are the most important standalone predictors, stock-based measures offer substantial incremental predictive power when considered alongside option-based characteristics. Finally, we provide compelling evidence that option return predictability is driven by informational frictions, costly arbitrage, and option mispricing.
21-09

Vikas Agarwal, Brad Barber, Si Cheng, Allaudeen Hameed, Ayako Yasuda

Private Company Valuations by Mutual Funds

published in: Review of Finance, Vol. 27, 2023, 693-738.
DOI: 10.1093/rof/rfac037

Mutual funds value private security holdings at considerably different prices, update valuations infrequently, and revise valuations dramatically at follow-on funding events. Predictable private valuation changes at follow-on rounds yield predictable fund returns, but effects are muted for large families, families with large investment in the private security, and families with large percentage stakes in funding rounds. Mutual funds with high exposure to private securities have outflows that are more sensitive to poor fund performance when the venture capital market also performs poorly. The results have welfare implications for retail investors interested in accessing private startups via investments in mutual funds.
21-10

Nerissa C. Brown, W. Brooke Elliott, Russ Wermers, Roger M. White

News or noise: Mobile internet technology and stock market activity

Mobile internet devices reduce trading frictions and information search costs for investors, but also introduce attention-competing activities, such as social networking. We use exogenous nationwide and citylevel outages of the Blackberry Internet Service (BIS) to investigate the effect of mobile internet technology on investors’ information-gathering vs. attention-diverting activities. We find that trading volume and trading frequency surge by about 5% on days when mobile internet systems go dark, consistent with a greater role for devices (when not dark) in diverting the limited attention of investors away from information-gathering and trading—even when they are used by presumably more sophisticated investors.
21-11

Vikas Agarwal, Honglin Ren, Ke Shen, Haibei Zhao

Redemption in Kind and Mutual Fund Liquidity Management

published in: Review of Financial Studies, Vol. 36, 2023, 2274-2318.
DOI: 10.1093/rfs/hhac080

Open-end mutual funds can use redemption in kind to satisfy investor redemptions by delivering securities instead of cash. We find that funds that reserve their rights to redeem in kind experience less redemption after poor performance. Evidence from actual in-kind transactions reveals several unique mechanisms for redemption in kind to mitigate fund runs, including the delivery of more illiquid stocks and stocks with greater tax overhang. Funds suffer less from the adverse impact of outflows on their performance. However, redeeming investors bear significant liquidation costs when they sell securities, which is associated with destabilization in the prices of these securities.
22-01

Tobias Bauckloh, Christian Klein, Thomas Pioch, Frank Schiemann

Under Pressure: The Link between Mandatory Climate Reporting and Firms’ Carbon Performance

published in: Organization & Environment, Vol. 36, 2023, 126-149.
DOI: 10.1177/10860266221083340

We examine whether mandatory climate reporting leads to changes in firms’ carbon emissions. Using propensity score matching and a difference-in-differences design, we assess the effects of the Greenhouse Gas Reporting Program (GHGRP), introduced by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in 2010, on the carbon performance defined as carbon intensity and absolute carbon emissions of affected firms. Institutional and legitimacy theory serve as theoretical underpinnings to investigate the degree to which firms comply with their ethical obligations. We find that firms affected by the GHGRP improve their carbon performance significantly more than unaffected firms after the introduction of the GHGRP, but not their absolute carbon emissions. The results are robust to changes in the difference-indifferences design and the matching sample. Overall, our study add to research on climaterelated disclosure regulation by assessing the GHGRP’s suitability as a regulatory measure to limit firms’ negative impacts on our climate.
22-02

Simon Lesmeister, Peter Limbach, P. Raghavendra Rau, Florian Sonnenburg

Indexing and the Performance-Flow Relation of Actively Managed Mutual Funds

We exploit the staggered introduction of index funds in different segments and countries to study how increased competition from indexing affects the performance-flow relation and incentives of actively managed equity mutual funds. An increase in the market shares of available country-level index funds in active fund benchmarks is associated with a significantly lower sensitivity of flows to past performance and with a shift from a convex performanceflow relation towards a more linear relation. The increased competition from index funds is also associated with a higher fund performance-liquidation sensitivity, suggesting real economic consequences for active fund managers and fund management companies.
22-03

André Betzer, Jasmin Gider, Peter Limbach

Do Financial Advisors Matter for M&A Pre-Announcement Returns?

This study documents economically meaningful and persistent financial advisor fixed effects in target firms’ abnormal stock returns shortly prior to takeover announcements. Additional difference-in-differences analyses suggest that advisors are associated with lower pre-bid stock returns after their senior staff were defendants in SEC insider trading enforcement actions. Returns are higher for advisors with more previously advised deals and those located in NYC. The evidence helps explain the prevalent phenomenon of prebid stock returns. It contributes to the inconclusive literature on banks’ exploitation of private information gained via advisory services, which is limited to disclosed, traceable activities indicative of information leakage.