Working Papers filtern

13-09

Mark J. Kamstra, Lisa A. Kramer, Maurice D. Levi, Russ Wermers

Seasonal Asset Allocation: Evidence from Mutual Fund Flows

veröffentlicht in: Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, Vol. 52, 2017, 71-109.
DOI: 10.1017/S002210901600082X

Over the past 30 years, mutual funds have become the dominant vehicle through which individual investors prepare for retirement via defined contribution plans. Further, money market mutual funds, which hold $2.7 trillion as of September 2013, are now a major part of the cash economy in the U.S. Accordingly, the flow of money to and from different mutual fund categories (e.g., equities vs. money funds) increasingly reflects the sentiment or risk aversion of the general population. In this study, we analyze flows between different categories of mutual funds, and find strong evidence of a seasonality in risk aversion of individual investors. Specifically, we find that aggregate investor flow data reveals an investor preference for U.S. money market and government bond mutual funds in the autumn, and equity funds in the spring, controlling for the influence of seasonality in past performance, advertising, liquidity needs, and capital gains overhang on fund flows. This movement of large amounts of money between fund categories is correlated with a proxy for variation in investor risk aversion across the seasons, consistent with investors’ revealed preferences for safer investments in the fall, and riskier investments in the spring. We find similar evidence in Canadian mutual fund flows, and in flows among Australian funds, where the seasons are six months out of phase relative to Canada and the U.S. While prior evidence regarding the influence of seasonally changing risk aversion on financial markets relies on seasonal patterns in asset returns, we provide the first direct trade-related evidence.
13-10

Vikas Agarwal, Linlin Ma, Kevin Mullally

Managerial Multitasking in the Mutual Fund Industry

veröffentlicht in: Financial Analysts Journal, Vol. 79, 2023, 65-75.
DOI: 10.1080/0015198X.2023.2182600

Managerial multitasking has become a common practice in the mutual fund industry. Although multitasking may have certain benefits for fund companies and portfolio managers, these arrangements have significant drawbacks for fund investors. We find that multitasking is associated with worse fund performance. Moreover, we find significant performance deterioration when single-tasking managers begin multitasking. We further provide evidence that multitasking limits the investment options of the fund managers or reduces the attention they allocate to their funds. Our study prescribes caution when assigning a portfolio manager with a greater workload as doing so adversely affects fund performance and, at some point, the ability of the fund family to attract capital.
13-11

Rainer Baule, Olaf Korn, Sven Saßning

Which Beta is Best? On the Information Content of Option-Implied Betas

veröffentlicht in: European Financial Management, Vol. 22, 2016, 450-483.
DOI: 10.1111/eufm.12065

Option-implied betas are a promising alternative to historical beta estimators, because they are inherently forward-looking and can incorporate new information immediately and fully. Recently, different implied beta estimators have been developed in previous literature, but very little is known about their properties and information content. This paper presents a first systematic comparison between six different implied beta estimators, which provides some guidance for applications and identifies directions for further improvements. The main results of the empirical study reveal that betas derived from implied variances are better predictors of realized betas than betas obtained from implied skewness, and that cross-sectional information from all stocks in the market improves beta estimation significantly. We also find that option-implied betas generally have a higher information content in periods of relatively high trading activity in options markets.
14-01

Nicholas F. Carline, Scott C. Linn, Pradeep Yadav

Corporate Governance and the Nature of Takeover Resistance

We investigate the relation between corporate governance characteristics of hostile takeover targets and the choice to employ ‘harmful’ resistance that is not perceived as being motivated by shareholders’ interests. We find that harmful resistance is associated with firms where managers have more pronounced ownership-based and age-related incentives for control, and directors have equity interests less aligned to stockholders. These firms also have less independent boards, are exposed to weaker discipline from outside blockholders, and are inferior performers. In the presence of harmful resistance, the market is less optimistic about the chances of bid completion, and there is a greater likelihood of managerial turnover.
14-02

Christian Andres, Markus Doumet, Erik Fernau, Erik Theissen

The Lintner model revisited: Dividends versus total payouts

veröffentlicht in: Journal of Banking and Finance, Vol. 55, 2015, 56-69.
DOI: 10.1016/j.jbankfin.2015.01.005

We analyze how the introduction of repurchases in 1998, and a major tax reform in 2001, affected the payout policy of German firms. To this end, we estimate Lintner (1956) partial adjustment models for both dividends and total payouts. We also analyze the implications for payout of changes in both permanent and transitory earnings. Our results are inconsistent with the hypothesis that dividends and repurchases are perfect substitutes. They are also inconsistent with the prediction that tax considerations are a major driver of payout decisions. Our results instead support the flexibility hypothesis that predicts that dividends are used to disburse permanent, and repurchases transitory, earnings.
14-03

Dieter Hess, Philipp Immenkötter

How Much Is Too Much? Debt Capacity and Financial Flexibility

We estimate the debt capacity of a firm as the critical debt ratio that causes a downgrade in creditworthiness. Unused debt capacities depict the temporal access to external debt funds and measure a firm’s financial flexibility. Firms with high unused debt capacities realize a larger fraction of their investment opportunity set, borrow more often, and issue higher volumes of debt. Firms that have exhausted their debt capacity issue equity or pay down debt when having a financial surplus. These patterns of actively using and restoring unused debt capacities imply that preserving financial flexibility is of first-order importance in corporate finance.
14-04

Christoph Sorhage

Outsourcing of Mutual Funds’ Non-core Competencies

Fund families strategically shape their member funds’ behavior to target specific groups of investors with varying performance and service needs. In this paper I introduce a new measure to identify performance-oriented and service-oriented funds. Matching theories from the industrial organization literature, I suggest that funds whose families outsource the execution of services unrelated to portfolio management to external specialists are the same funds with an emphasis on their core business portfolio management. I find an outperformance of serviceoutsourced funds that is robust to a range of alternative explanations. Moreover, I show evidence that service-outsourced funds indeed possess superior investment skills.
14-05

Joachim Grammig, Eva-Maria Schaub

Give me strong moments and time – Combining GMM and SMM to estimate long-run risk asset pricing models

The long-run consumption risk (LRR) model is a promising approach to resolve prominent asset pricing puzzles. The simulated method of moments (SMM) provides a natural framework to estimate its deep parameters, but caveats concern model solubility and weak identification. We propose a twostep estimation strategy that combines GMM and SMM, and for which we elicit informative macroeconomic and financial moment matches from the LRR model structure. In particular, we exploit the persistent serial correlation of consumption and dividend growth and the equilibrium conditions for market return and risk-free rate, as well as the model-implied predictability of the risk-free rate. We match analytical moments when possible and simulated moments when necessary and determine the crucial factors required for both identification and reasonable estimation precision. A simulation study—the first in the context of long-run risk modeling—delineates the pitfalls associated with SMM estimation of a non-linear dynamic asset pricing model. Our study provides a blueprint for successful estimation of the LRR model.
14-06

Joachim Grammig, Jantje Sönksen

Empirical Asset Pricing with Multi-Period Disaster Risk: A Simulation-Based Approach

veröffentlicht in: Journal of Econometrics, Vol. 222, 2021, 805-832.
DOI: 10.1016/j.jeconom.2020.08.001

We propose a simulation-based strategy to estimate and empirically assess a class of asset pricing models that account for rare but severe consumption contractions that can extend over multiple periods. Our approach expands the scope of prevalent calibration studies and tackles the inherent sample selection problem associated with measuring the effect of rare disaster risk on asset prices. An analysis based on postwar U.S. and historical multi-country panel data yields estimates of investor preference parameters that are economically plausible and robust with respect to alternative specifications. The estimated model withstands tests of validity; the model-implied key financial indicators and timing premium all have reasonable magnitudes. These findings suggest that the rare disaster hypothesis can help restore the nexus between the real economy and financial markets when allowing for multi-period disaster events. Our methodological contribution is a new econometric framework for empirical asset pricing with rare disaster risk.
14-07

Felix Brinkmann, Olaf Korn

Risk-adjusted Option-implied Moments

veröffentlicht in: Review of Derivatives Research, Vol. 21, 2018, 149-173.
DOI: 10.1007/s11147-017-9136-4

Option-implied moments, like implied volatility, contain useful information about an underlying asset’s return distribution, but are derived under the risk-neutral probability measure. This paper shows how to convert risk-neutral moments into the corresponding physical ones. The main theoretical result expresses moments under the physical probability measure in terms of observed option prices and the preferences of a representative investor. Based on this result, we investigate several empirical questions. We show that a model of a representative investor with CRRA utility can explain the variance risk premium for the S&P500 index but fails to capture variance and skewness risk premiums simultaneously. Moreover, we present methods to estimate forward-looking market risk premiums and investors’ disappointment aversion implied in market prices.