23-04
Vikas Agarwal, Brad Barber, Si Cheng, Allaudeen Hameed, Harshini Shanker, Ayako Yasuda
Do Investors Overvalue Startups? Evidence from the Junior Stakes of Mutual Funds
We show that mutual funds report their junior stakes in startups at 43% higher valuation than model fair values that consider multi-tier capital structures of startups. The latest-issued and most senior security is worth 48% per share than junior securities held by mutual funds, implying that mutual funds mark junior securities close to par with the senior securities. Our findings are robust to model assumptions. Identical valuations reported for dual holdings of senior and junior securities imply 37% discrepancy in implied values of the firm. Overvaluation is lower for fund families with longer experience in private startup investments, and higher for junior securities purchased in secondary transactions. Overvaluation declines after down rounds (new financing rounds with purchase prices lower than previous rounds) and near IPOs. The results are consistent with mutual funds neglecting the probability of negative outcomes in which junior securities are paid less than senior securities and overweighting successful exits where all securities convert to common equity and are valued equally.
23-03
Tobias Bauckloh, Maurice Dumrose, André Höck, Christian Klein
ESG Criteria and the Credit Risk of Corporate Bond Portfolios
veröffentlicht in:
Journal of Asset Management, Vol. 24, 2023, 572-580.
DOI:
10.1057/s41260-023-00337-w
Demand for sustainable fixed-income investment solutions is surging but there is hardly research on the impact of sustainability on the risk characteristics of fixed-income portfolios. This study examines the impact of sustainability on the credit risk exposure of U.S. corporate bond portfolios between 2013 and 2020 by analyzing the returns of sustainable and non-sustainable portfolios using two different asset pricing models and environmental, social, and governance (ESG) ratings from different providers. Controlling for a set of portfolio characteristics, our results show that sustainable portfolios are significantly less exposed to credit risk than their non-sustainable peer portfolios. This finding implies that considering ESG criteria in portfolio management is a suitable means to systematically manage credit risk. Being the first study to investigate the relationship between sustainability and credit risk on portfolio level, this study contributes to the understanding of the effects of ESG criteria in portfolio management and provides academics and investment professionals with valuable insights.
23-02
Tobias Bauckloh, Juris Dobrick, André Höck, Sebastian Utz, Marcus Wagner
In Partnership for the Goals? The Level of Agreement Between SDG Ratings
veröffentlicht in:
Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, Vol. 217, 2024, 664-678.
DOI:
10.1016/j.jebo.2023.11.014
This study analyzes the level of agreement of Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) ratings across five different rating providers. It documents a low level of agreement that is particularly pronounced for companies from the Energy, Healthcare, and Basic Materials sector. Moreover, the low level of agreement is mostly driven by some individual SDGs. When analyzing implications, we find different return characteristics and risk factor exposures of portfolios sorted according to SDG ratings of different rating providers. Overall, our analyses show that current SDG ratings fail to provide a clear signal of companies’ contribution to the SDGs which can have severe consequences for sustainability transitions and their financing.
23-01
Frederik Simon, Sebastian Weibels, Tom Zimmermann
Deep Parametric Portfolio Policies
erscheint in:
Management Science.
We consider parametric portfolio policies of any complexity using deep neural networks to optimize investor utility. Risk aversion acts as an economic regularization mechanism, with higher risk aversion constraining model complexity. Empirically, Deep Parametric Portfolio Policies (DPPP) generate 43-102 basis points higher monthly certainty equivalent returns compared to linear policies. Looking beyond expected returns, non-linear portfolio policies better capture the complex relationship between investor preferences and firm characteristics but the benefits of using complex models vary with investor preferences. Results hold across different utility functions and remain robust to transaction costs and short-selling restrictions.
22-12
Vikas Agarwal, Alexander Cochardt, Vitaly Orlov
Birth Order and Fund Manager’s Trading Behavior: Role of Sibling Rivalry
veröffentlicht in:
Journal of Corporate Finance, Vol. 95, 2025, article 102852.
DOI:
10.1016/j.jcorpfin.2025.102852
This paper investigates the role of birth order on managerial behavior using rich data on familial background of US mutual fund managers. We find that managers who are born later in the sibling hierarchy take on more investment risks relative to first-born managers, but perform worse. Motivated by sensation seeking, later-born managers take extreme style bets, hold more lottery stocks, and report more civil and regulatory violations compared to lower-birth-order managers. Taken together, our findings suggest that birth order-induced sensation seeking tendencies originate from sibling rivalry for limited parental resources during childhood, shape trading behavior, and extend beyond portfolio management.
22-11
Gjergji Cici, Scott Gibson, Nan Qin, Alex Zhang
The Performance of Corporate Bond Mutual Funds and the Allocation of Underpriced New Issues
Using a novel return-based method to detect allocations of corporate bond offerings, which are underpriced on average, we find that mutual funds most active in the primary market generate significant alpha and outperform those that are less active. Our evidence suggests that underwriters direct underpriced allocations repeatedly to fund families with which they have stronger underwriting relationships. Consistent with the concave performance-flow relationship that describes bond fund investors’ behavior, families maximize profitability by strategically distributing allocations to member funds that underperformed their style benchmark over the last year at the expense of those that outperformed.
22-10
Erik Theissen, Christian Westheide
One for the Money, Two for the Show? The Number of Designated Market Makers and Liquidity
veröffentlicht in:
Economics Letters, Vol. 224, 2023, article 110992.
DOI:
10.1016/j.econlet.2023.110992
Prior research has established that the presence of designated market makers (DMMs) in an electronic open limit order book increases liquidity. We analyze whether the presence of additional DMMs results in a further improvement in liquidity. Using data from Deutsche B¨orse’s Xetra system we find that increases in the number of DMMs significantly improve liquidity, and vice versa for decreases in the number of DMMs. Our results are confirmed when we use an instrumental variables approach to overcome potential endogeneity issues.
22-09
Robert Campbell, Peter Limbach, Johannes Reusche
Once Bitten, Twice Shy: Failed Deals and Subsequent M&A Cautiousness
Companies occasionally are unable to finalize publicly announced M&A bids—a phenomenon we refer to as failed deals. Despite their commonality, the implications of failed deals for bidding firms are not well understood. We thus theorize about and empirically investigate the relationship between failed deals and subsequent M&A behavior. In doing so, we present multiple reasons for what we term “the once bitten, twice shy effect,” whereby firms act more cautiously in the M&A context following failed deals. In a sample of M&As across North American and European firms, we find empirical support consistent with our theorizing suggesting the cautiousness following failed deals results in a longer time-period between M&A bids, smaller target firm size, and a greater likelihood of advisor usage.
22-08
Monika Gehde-Trapp, Linda Klingler
The Effect of Sentiment on Institutional Investors: A Gender Analysis
In this paper, we explore whether male and female fund managers react differently to sentiment. Our main idea is that sentiment indicates mispricings of stocks relative to their fundamental values, and that rational fund managers should profit from these mispricings. As trading against the mispricing is risky, we hypothesize that female fund managers take on less aggressive positions. Indeed, our empirical results show that male fund managers hold portfolios with significantly higher total fund risk and unsystematic risk when sentiment is bad. For female fund managers, we find significantly lower levels in unsystematic risk when sentiment is bad. This difference in risk-taking behavior does not affect fund returns or riskadjusted performance.
22-07
Tobias Bauckloh, Victor Beyer, Christian Klein
Does it Pay to Invest in Dirty Industries? – New Insights on the Shunned-Stock Hypothesis
This research examines whether stocks of firms operating in highly polluting industries (“dirty stocks”) are treated like sin stocks. We assume that investors shun dirty stocks based on non-pecuniary preferences and employ screening approaches that lead to the exclusion of entire industries. Using emission data of the U.S. Toxics Release Inventory, we show that dirty stocks are held in lower proportions by institutional investors and are followed by fewer financial analysts than other stocks. The shunning leads to an outperformance of dirty stocks in cross-sectional and time-series return analyses. These observations affect all firms within a dirty industry, regardless of whether they have high or low TRI emissions. This means that comparatively clean firms are shunned by capital market participants simply because of their industry affiliation, which can result in financing disadvantages and low incentives to improve sustainability performance. Thus, our findings contribute to the understanding of environmental preferences of investors and their consequences for asset pricing.