Filtering Working Papers

06-05

Silke Ber, Stefan Ruenzi

On the Usability of Synthetic Measures of Mutual Fund Net-Flows

Due to a lack of data availability, numerous empirical studies on mutual fund flows (e.g. Sirri/Tufano (1998)) analyze synthetically derived flow measures. We show how good these measures can explain actual flows. We compare the measures suggested in the literature with the actual net-flows of all German equity mutual funds. Our results show the appropriateness of the synthetic measures used in previous studies. Inference about the influence of past performance on flows is not biased by using synthetic instead of actual measures of fund flows. Thus, we offer a justification for the use of synthetic measures in performance flow studies.
06-06

Jan P. Krahnen, Frank A. Schmid, Erik Theissen

Investment Performance and Market Share: A Study of the German Mutual Fund Industry

published in: Bessler, Wolfgang (Hrsg.): Börsen, Banken und Kapitalmärkte. Festschrift für Hartmut Schmidt zum 65. Geburtstag, Duncker & Humblot, Berlin, 2006, 471-491.

We study a set of German open-end mutual funds for a time period during which this industry emerged from its infancy. In those years, the distribution channel for mutual funds was dominated by the brick-and-mortar retail networks of the large universal banks. Using monthly observations from 12/1986 through 12/1998, we investigate if cross-sectional return differences across mutual funds affect their market shares. Although such a causal relation has been established in highly competitive markets, such as the United States, the rigid distribution system in place in Germany at the time may have caused retail performance and investment performance to uncouple. In fact, although we observe stark differences in investment performance across mutual funds (and over time), we find no evidence that cross-sectional performance differences affect the market shares of these funds.
06-07

Kerstin Drachter, Alexander Kempf, Michael Wagner

Decision Processes in German Mutual Fund Companies: Evidence from a Telephone Survey

published in: International Journal of Managerial Finance, Vol. 3, 2007, 49-69.
DOI: 10.1108/17439130710721653

The performance of actively managed mutual funds is largely dependent upon the investment decisions of the responsible fund managers. However, little is known about the behavior of these managers. This survey study sheds light on the decision processes of German fund managers. The design of the survey allows us to link fund manager data with information about mutual funds and fund management companies. This synthesis results in improved understanding of the mutual fund management decision process. The evidence shows that (i) it is possible to conduct a high quality survey study even though managers know that their answers will be linked to their performance and (ii) the behavior of managers depends heavily on the characteristics of the funds and the characteristics of the fund company.
06-08

Mathias Hoffmann, Bernd Kempa

The Poole Analysis in the New Open Economy Macroeconomic Framework

published in: Review of International Economics, Vol. 17, 2009, 1074-1097.
DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-9396.2009.00810.x

This paper evaluates simple, non-optimising monetary policy rules in the tradition of the well-known Poole analysis within a general two-country open-economy model of the New Open Economy Macroeconomic framework. Pure money supply rules are compared with simple interest rate rules for the large and the small open economy. The results for the large economy resemble those of the original Poole analysis. This is also confirmed when considering welfare. In particular, an interest rate rule yields superior results with respect to liquidity shocks whereas a money supply rule is preferable when real shock predominate. In the small open economy scenario the results of the large economy case continue to hold for domestic shocks. For foreign shocks, welfare improves under an interest rate rule relative to a money supply rule when real shocks are considered and the impact on real money balances is neglected. The reverse holds for foreign liquidity shocks. In all scenarios an interest rate rule stabilises domestic consumption.
06-09

Russ Wermers, Tong Yao, Jane Zhao

Forecasting Stock Returns Through an Efficient Aggregation of Mutual Fund Holdings

published in: Review of Financial Studies, Vol. 25, 2012, 3490-3529.
DOI: 10.1093/rfs/hhs111

We develop a stock return-predictive measure based on an efficient aggregation of the portfolio holdings of all actively managed U.S. domestic equity mutual funds, and use this model to study the source of fund managers’ stock-selection abilities. This “generalized-inverse alpha” (GIA) approach reveals differences in the ability of managers to predict firms’ future earnings from fundamental research. Notably, the GIA’s return-forecasting power is not subsumed by publicly available quantitative predictors, such as momentum, value, and earnings quality, nor is it subsumed by methods shown in past research to forecast stock returns using fund holdings or trades.
06-10

Alexander Kempf, Peer Osthoff

The Effect of Socially Responsible Investing on Portfolio Performance

published in: European Financial Management, Vol. 13, 2007, 908-922.
DOI: 10.1111/j.1468-036X.2007.00402.x

More and more investors apply socially responsible screens when building their stock portfolios. This raises the question whether these investors can increase their performance by incorporating such screens into their investment process. To answer this question we implement a simple trading strategy based on socially responsible ratings from the KLD Research & Analytics: Buy stocks with high socially responsible ratings and sell stocks with low socially responsible ratings. We find that this strategy leads to high abnormal returns of up to 8.7% per year. The maximum abnormal returns are reached when investors employ the best-in-class screening approach, use a combination of several socially responsible screens at the same time, and restrict themselves to stocks with extreme socially responsible ratings. The abnormal returns remain significant even after taking into account reasonable transaction costs.
06-11

Stefan Ruenzi, Ulf von Lilienfeld-Toal

Why Managers Hold Shares of Their Firm: An Empirical Analysis

published in: Journal of Finance, Vol. 69, 2014, 1013-1050.
DOI: 10.1111/jofi.12139

We examine the relationship between CEO ownership and stock market performance of S&P 500 (S&P 1500) firms from 1994-2005 (1996-2005). We find that firms in which the CEO holds a considerable share of outstanding stocks outperform the market by up to 16% p.a. after controlling for traditional risk factors like size, book-to-market and momentum. This offers an explanation why so many CEOs hold a large fraction of their own company’s stocks. They do so simply because it pays. We also examine several potential explanations why the existence of an owner CEO is not fully priced but leads to abnormal returns.
06-12

Russ Wermers, Youchang Wu, Josef Zechner

Portfolio Performance, Discount Dynamics, and the Turnover of Closed-End Fund Managers

This paper provides new evidence supporting the rationality of closed-end fund discounts by analyzing the time-series dynamics of individual fund discounts and their relation to portfolio performance and manager turnover. We show that discount changes reflect rational investor learning about fund manager skills, as well as investor anticipation of manager replacement events. Specifically, prior to the replacement of a manager, the fund’s discount initially increases as fund performance worsens – for domestic equity funds, the peer-adjusted discount increases by about 3 percent during year -2 (relative to the manager replacement event), which is sizable, compared to the average closed-end fund discount of 5.6 percent at the end of 2002. However, after this initial increase, the discount does not respond to continuing underperformance by the manager, indicating that investors rationally anticipate that the manager will be replaced. Overall, our study demonstrates that a significant rational component exists in closed-end fund discounts.
06-13

Sanela Celjo-Hörhager, Alexandra Niessen-Ruenzi

How do Self-fulfilling Prophecies affect Financial Ratings? An experimental study

In this experimental study we examine the impact of self-fulfilling prophecies on financial ratings. According to theoretical models like Kuhner (2001), rating agencies are more likely to reveal their private information if their rating can not become self-fulfilling from an ex-post point of view. In our experiment we use two settings in which ratings differ with respect to the degree of their self-fulfilling impact. In connection with a strong self-fulfilling impact of ratings we indeed observe that agencies are more likely to assign ratings which are not in line with their private information. Our results support theoretical findings of Kuhner (2001). However, the pathological equilibrium predicted by the theoretical model does not emerge in our experiment.
07-01

Meike Hagemeister, Alexander Kempf

CAPM und erwartete Renditen: Eine Untersuchung auf Basis der Erwartung von Marktteilnehmern

published in: DBW - Die Betriebswirtschaft, Vol. 70, 2010, 145-164.